Heritage Diner, diner in Mt Sinai, Brookhaven

Eat & drink

Oldest restaurants in Brookhaven, 2026

Brookhaven’s longest-running restaurants: 6 local places, oldest first, by the year each one says it opened.

Updated November 2026 · 6 independent places in Brookhaven · facts from each business’s own website

The list

Oldest restaurants in Brookhaven

6 places in Brookhaven.

  1. Country Corner

    East Setauket

    Open since 1909 (117 years)

    our bar has been a cherished gathering spot since 1909. per their website (countrycornerli.com), checked November 2026

    270 Main St, East Setauket, NY 11733

  2. La Grova Ristorante

    Lake Grove

    Open since 1978 (48 years)

    Established in 1978… per their website (lagrova.com), checked November 2026

    Tue–Thu 11 AM–8 PM · Fri 11 AM–8:30 PM · Sat, Sun 11 AM–8 PM · closed Mon

    2799 Middle Country Rd, Lake Grove, NY 11755

  3. Seaport Diner

    Port Jefferson Station

    Open since 1981 (45 years)

    A Port Jefferson Station diner, family owned since 1981. per their website (seaportdinerli.com), checked November 2026

    Mon–Thu 8 AM–10 AM · Fri, Sat 8 AM–11 AM · Sun 8 AM–10 AM

    5045 Nesconset Hwy, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776

  4. Mama Lisa Restaurant

    Mastic

    Open since 1999 (27 years)

    Mama Lisa Restaurant was founded in 1999 by Gaetano and Mose Costigliola. per their website (mamalisarestaurant.com), checked November 2026

    Mon–Thu 11 AM–10 PM · Fri, Sat 11 AM–10:30 PM · Sun 11 AM–10 PM

    1226 Montauk Hwy, Mastic, NY 11950

  5. Heritage Diner

    Mt Sinai

    Open since 2000 (26 years)

    Mount Sinai, NY · Since 2000 per their website (heritagediner.com), checked November 2026

    275 Route 25A, Mt Sinai, NY 11766

  6. B L D's Restaurant

    Ronkonkoma

    Open since 2001 (25 years)

    We have been serving the community since 2001. per their website (bldsrestaurant.net), checked November 2026

    Mon–Sat 7 AM–9 PM · Sun 7 AM–8 PM

    299 Hawkins Ave, Ronkonkoma, NY 11779

Map

Where they are in Brookhaven

Map of 6 places loads as you scroll.

How we checked

A place is listed when its own website states the year it opened ("since 1952", "established 1948") or Wikidata records its founding year; if the two disagree it is left out. Shown: places open 50 years or more, or the city’s ten oldest that have been open 25 years or more, oldest first.

Each entry is a fact the business states on its own website. We fetched the homepage of every listed Brookhaven restaurant and bar that links its own site, plus up to three pages on the same site (menu, specials, events or about), and kept only explicit statements, quoted with a link to the page they came from.

Checked November 2026. A claim more than 12 months old is dropped. Menus, specials and event nights change, so confirm with the business before you go.

Only independent local businesses in this guide’s Brookhaven directory are included: no chains and no places outside Brookhaven. A business whose website does not state the fact is not listed here, which does not mean it lacks it.

Sites that block automated visits, or ask robots not to visit, were skipped rather than worked around.

Questions

Oldest restaurants in Brookhaven: answers

What is the oldest restaurant in Brookhaven?

By the year it states, Country Corner: open since 1909 (117 years). This counts only restaurants in this guide’s directory that state a year.

Which Brookhaven restaurants have been open 50 years or more?

1: Country Corner.

Which are the five oldest?

Country Corner (1909), La Grova Ristorante (1978), Seaport Diner (1981), Mama Lisa Restaurant (1999) and Heritage Diner (2000).

Is the opening year the same business at the same address?

Not always. The year is the one each business gives, which can include earlier locations or owners.

How is this list made?

A place is listed when its own website states the year it opened ("since 1952", "established 1948") or Wikidata records its founding year; if the two disagree it is left out. Shown: places open 50 years or more, or the city’s ten oldest that have been open 25 years or more, oldest first. Checked November 2026.

Brookhaven AI

Your Brookhaven local guide
Hey there!

I'm Brookhaven AI. Ask about neighborhood food, independent shops, local history or planning a visit.

AI recommendations may be inaccurate. Verify hours and prices. Questions are processed by Cloudflare. Privacy