Port Jefferson Village Historic District

Eat & drink

Desserts in Brookhaven, 2026

Dessert in Brookhaven: 7 local places across 3 kinds: ice cream, donuts and bakeries.

Updated October 2026 · 7 independent places in Brookhaven

2 places

Ice cream, gelato & frozen treats

2 places in Brookhaven.

  1. Ice Cream Cottage

    Mastic

    Open until 10:30 PM Fri, Sat

    Mon–Thu 10 AM–10 PM · Fri, Sat 10 AM–10:30 PM · Sun 10 AM–10 PM

    1590 Montauk Hwy, Mastic, NY 11950

  2. McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor

    Miller Place

    Open until 10 PM Fri, Sat

    Good to know: They offer milkshakes, ice cream floats, and ice cream sandwiches.

    Mon–Thu 11 AM–9 PM · Fri, Sat 11 AM–10 PM · Sun 11 AM–9 PM

    153 N Country Rd, Miller Place, NY 11764

1 place

Donuts

1 place in Brookhaven.

  1. Glenn's Donuts

    Selden

    Open until 7 PM Wed–Sat

    Good to know: Closed Mondays and Tuesdays.

    Wed–Sat 8 AM–7 PM · Sun 8 AM–3 PM · closed Mon, Tue

    203 Independence Plz, Selden, NY 11784

4 places

Bakeries & pastry shops

4 places in Brookhaven.

  1. Mademoiselle

    Patchogue

    Open until 4 PM Thu–Sun

    Good to know: The bakery's menu features desserts like French macarons and seasonal tarts.

    Thu–Sun 10 AM–4 PM · closed Mon–Wed

    61 N Ocean Ave, Patchogue, NY 11772

  2. Sugar Dreams Bakery

    East Patchogue

    Open until 6 PM Tue–Sat

    Good to know: Closed Mondays.

    Tue–Sat 9 AM–6 PM · Sun 10 AM–3 PM · closed Mon

    15 S Country Rd, East Patchogue, NY 11772

  3. The Bread Palace Bakery & Cafe

    Farmingville

    Open until 8 PM daily

    Mon–Sat 4 AM–8 PM · Sun 5 AM–8 PM

    750 Horseblock Rd, Farmingville, NY 11738

  4. Benkert's Bakery

    Centereach

    Open until 6 PM daily

    Good to know: The bakery is owned by the Lorch and Janke families, who have been providing baked goods to the area for multiple generations.

    Mon–Fri 7 AM–6 PM · Sat, Sun 6 AM–6 PM

    2216 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720

Map

Where they are in Brookhaven

Map of 7 places loads as you scroll.

How this list is made

A place is listed when its kind is an ice cream, gelato or frozen yogurt shop, a bakery or pastry shop, a donut shop, a boba or bubble tea shop, or a dessert or sweets shop.

Only independent local businesses in this guide’s Brookhaven directory are included: no chains and no places outside Brookhaven. Listings that are held or unpublished are left out.

Hours are each business’s posted weekly schedule as saved in this guide. They can change and do not cover holidays, so confirm before you go.

Updated October 2026.

Questions

Desserts in Brookhaven: answers

Where can I get dessert in Brookhaven?

This guide lists 7 independent dessert spots in Brookhaven: ice cream, gelato & frozen treats (2), donuts (1) and bakeries & pastry shops (4).

Where can I find bakeries & pastry shops in Brookhaven?

This guide lists 4: Mademoiselle, Sugar Dreams Bakery, The Bread Palace Bakery & Cafe and Benkert's Bakery.

Where can I find ice cream, gelato & frozen treats in Brookhaven?

This guide lists 2: Ice Cream Cottage and McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor.

Where can I find donuts in Brookhaven?

This guide lists 1: Glenn's Donuts.

Which Brookhaven dessert spots are open late?

By posted hours: Ice Cream Cottage (open until 10:30 PM) and McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor (open until 10 PM).

How is this list made?

A place is listed when its kind is an ice cream, gelato or frozen yogurt shop, a bakery or pastry shop, a donut shop, a boba or bubble tea shop, or a dessert or sweets shop. Hours are each business’s posted weekly schedule as saved in this guide. They can change and do not cover holidays, so confirm before you go.

Brookhaven AI

Your Brookhaven local guide
Hey there!

I'm Brookhaven AI. Ask about neighborhood food, independent shops, local history or planning a visit.

AI recommendations may be inaccurate. Verify hours and prices. Questions are processed by Cloudflare. Privacy