Station prices
Gas prices in Brookhaven
Reported prices at 15 nearby stations, lowest first. Compare regular, midgrade, premium and diesel; check each report’s date before you drive.
Lowest reported gas prices near Brookhaven
BJ's Gas Station, 790 Sunrise Hwy, Bellport: $4.00 for regular, 25¢ under the 15-station average of $4.25. This regular price was reported 2 days ago; confirm at the pump.
- Cheapest regular$4.00BJ's Gas Station, 790 Sunrise Hwy, Bellport
- Average regular$4.2515 stations · New York City area weekly average $4.25
- Highest regular$4.50East Patchogue Valero, 151 Hospital Rd, East Patchogue
- Cheapest diesel$6.15BJ's Gas Station, 790 Sunrise Hwy, Bellport
- Cheapest premium$4.88BJ's Gas Station, 790 Sunrise Hwy, Bellport
- Cheapest midgrade$4.60Mobil, 2771 NY-112, Medford
Filling a 15-gallon tank at the cheapest station instead of the most expensive saves about $7.50 (50¢ a gallon).
The cheapest regular here is 25¢ below the New York City area weekly average of $4.25; the local station average is the same.
- 1BJ's Gas Station790 Sunrise Hwy, Bellport · 4.9 mi$4.00regular · 2 days ago
- 2Sam's Club Gas Station2950 Horseblock Road, Medford · 4.1 mi$4.00regular · 3 days ago
- 3Mobil2771 NY-112, Medford · 4.3 mi$4.10regular · 2 days ago
- 4Shell737 Montauk Hwy, Shirley · 4.7 mi$4.16regular · 3 days ago
- 5bp741 Montauk Hwy, Shirley · 4.7 mi$4.20regular · 3 days ago
- 6bp1258 Middle Country Rd, Selden · 7.0 mi$4.22regular · 3 days ago
- 77-Eleven525 William Floyd Pkwy, Shirley · 5.2 mi$4.26regular · 2 days ago
- 8Speedway80A Horseblock Road, Yaphank · 3.5 mi$4.26regular · 3 days ago
- 9Mobil285 Wading River Rd, Manorville · 6.4 mi$4.30regular · 2 days ago
- 10Mobil1801 N Ocean Ave, Medford · 5.5 mi$4.30regular · 2 days ago
- 11Mobil1889 NY-112, Coram · 5.3 mi$4.30regular · 3 days ago
- 12Sunoco1741 Montauk Hwy, Bellport · 5.7 mi$4.30regular · 3 days ago
- 13bp975 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island · 2.1 mi$4.36regular · 3 days ago
- 14Mobil1430 William Floyd Pkwy, Shirley · 2.4 mi$4.46regular · 3 days ago
- 15East Patchogue Valero151 Hospital Rd, East Patchogue · 5.6 mi$4.50regular · 3 days ago
Gas price map
Green pins are the cheapest third. Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors via OpenFreeMap.
Cheapest diesel in Brookhaven
- BJ's Gas Station790 Sunrise Hwy, Bellport · 4.9 mi$6.15
- Sam's Club Gas Station2950 Horseblock Road, Medford · 4.1 mi$6.15
- Mobil2771 NY-112, Medford · 4.3 mi$6.40
- Mobil1889 NY-112, Coram · 5.3 mi$6.48
- Mobil285 Wading River Rd, Manorville · 6.4 mi$6.50
Average diesel: $6.42 at 8 stations.
Cheapest premium in Brookhaven
- BJ's Gas Station790 Sunrise Hwy, Bellport · 4.9 mi$4.88
- Sam's Club Gas Station2950 Horseblock Road, Medford · 4.1 mi$4.88
- Mobil2771 NY-112, Medford · 4.3 mi$5.00
- Mobil1889 NY-112, Coram · 5.3 mi$5.10
- 7-Eleven525 William Floyd Pkwy, Shirley · 5.2 mi$5.16
Average premium: $5.12 at 8 stations.
Cheapest midgrade in Brookhaven
- Mobil2771 NY-112, Medford · 4.3 mi$4.60
- 7-Eleven525 William Floyd Pkwy, Shirley · 5.2 mi$4.76
- Mobil285 Wading River Rd, Manorville · 6.4 mi$4.80
- Mobil1801 N Ocean Ave, Medford · 5.5 mi$4.80
Average midgrade: $4.74 at 4 stations.
Gas prices by brand in Brookhaven
| Brand | Stations | Average regular | Cheapest |
|---|---|---|---|
| bp | 3 | $4.26 | $4.20 741 Montauk Hwy, Shirley |
| Mobil | 5 | $4.29 | $4.10 2771 NY-112, Medford |
Reported prices from Google Maps for stations within ten miles of Brookhaven. Shared gas-check turns are scheduled daily within the free-request budget. The requesting city and stations rotate, so not every city or station is rechecked daily. Prices keep their Google Maps report dates; a successful check does not guarantee a new or changed price. Provider outages or allowance limits can delay checks. Reports older than four days are left out. Confirm at the pump.
Average regular gas · New York City area
$4.25/gal
Week of October 19, 2026 · down 7¢ from the week before, down 12¢ across 6 weekly observations
- New York$4.316¢ more than New York City area
- U.S. average$4.284¢ more than New York City area
- $4.37Sep 14
- $4.41Sep 21
- $4.38Sep 28
- $4.34Oct 5
- $4.31Oct 12
- $4.25Oct 19
Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration, weekly retail gasoline prices (regular, all formulations, including taxes). Averages for the area, not a price at any one station.
Save on gas in Brookhaven
- Check the posted pump price and any payment or membership conditions before filling up.
- Compare available station prices along your route; the regional average is not a quote for a particular station.
- If a station advertises a discount, check its eligibility and payment terms.
- Planning a drive? See getting around Brookhaven and our commute page.
Questions
Where are the lowest reported gas prices near Brookhaven?
BJ's Gas Station at 790 Sunrise Hwy, Bellport had regular for $4.00 a gallon, reported 2 days ago: the lowest of 15 stations with reported regular prices within ten miles. This is not a citywide minimum or a live pump-price guarantee. Next were Sam's Club Gas Station ($4.00) and Mobil ($4.10).
What is the average gas price in Brookhaven?
Regular averages $4.25 a gallon across 15 stations, from $4.00 to $4.50. Midgrade averages $4.74. Premium averages $5.12. Diesel averages $6.42. The New York City area weekly average for regular is $4.25.
Where is the cheapest diesel in Brookhaven?
BJ's Gas Station at 790 Sunrise Hwy, Bellport, at $6.15 a gallon (updated 2 days ago).
Which gas station brand is cheapest in Brookhaven?
bp, averaging $4.26 for regular at 3 stations, compared with $4.29 at Mobil.
How often are Brookhaven gas prices updated?
Shared gas-check turns are scheduled daily within the free-request budget. The requesting city and stations rotate, so not every city or station is rechecked daily. Prices keep their Google Maps report dates; a successful check does not guarantee a new or changed price. Provider outages or allowance limits can delay checks. Reports older than four days are left out.
What is the weekly EIA gas-price comparison for Brookhaven?
For the week of October 19, 2026, regular gasoline averaged $4.25 a gallon in the EIA New York City area survey area, compared with $4.28 nationally. This is a metropolitan-area comparison, not a separate average for Brookhaven or a live station price.
Where does the weekly average come from?
From the U.S. Energy Information Administration’s weekly survey of retail gasoline prices, published every Monday. This page uses the New York City area as a metropolitan-area comparison. It is not a separate average for Brookhaven.
Why is the price at my Brookhaven station different?
Stations set their own prices, and this is an average across many stations for the whole area. Brand, location, cash or card and membership discounts all change the price at the pump.
When do these numbers update?
EIA publishes new averages each Monday afternoon (Tuesday after a Monday holiday). This page checks for the new week twice a day.