Brookhaven source photograph

Compare cities

Brookhaven vs Islip

Two New York cities 20 miles apart, side by side.

BrookhavenIslip
Population3,08017,224
Median household income$95,345$122,596
Median home value$577,000$486,900
Median rent$1,908/mo$2,192/mo
Median age49.944
Homeownership74%84%
Property tax (effective)1.73%2.05%
Sales tax8.75%8.75%
Median home value
  • Brookhaven$577,000
  • Islip$486,900
Median household income
  • Brookhaven$95,345
  • Islip$122,596
Median rent
  • Brookhaven$1,908
  • Islip$2,192

Explore both

Questions

Is Brookhaven or Islip cheaper?

For housing, Islip is cheaper: median home values are $577,000 in Brookhaven and $486,900 in Islip; median rents are $1,908 and $2,192.

Which has higher incomes, Brookhaven or Islip?

Islip: median household income is $95,345 in Brookhaven and $122,596 in Islip.

How far is Brookhaven from Islip?

About 20 miles in a straight line.

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2019–2023 5-year estimates; state revenue agencies for sales tax.

Brookhaven AI

Your Brookhaven local guide
Hey there!

I'm Brookhaven AI. Ask about neighborhood food, independent shops, local history or planning a visit.

AI recommendations may be inaccurate. Verify hours and prices. Questions are processed by Cloudflare. Privacy